The never ending controversy over the anthropic principle

It would take little more than a bit of tinkering with the constants of nature or the laws of atomic physics to make life as we know it disappear in a flash, or even not to have ever occurred in the first place. Advocates of the anthropic principle argue that such fine craftsmanship can only come from a higher, benevolent entity that has created a universe for us to observe and marvel at. In contrast, critics of the anthropic principle are not satisfied with this reasoning, which they call childish, circular, and intellectually comfortable. Instead, they argue, the intricate lacework in which we live is nothing but the product of the impersonal laws of mathematics, physics, and statistics.

The anthropic principle claims that the universe is fine-tuned precisely to allow for human life. This means that the physical laws and constants of the universe are suitable for the existence of life, suggesting a coincidence that is beyond huge. If these physical constants were slightly different, life would not be possible.

This coincidence has led some to believe that the universe is being guided by an intelligent force. While this is undoubtedly a theological possibility, it is also a scientific explanation, albeit a poor one. The multiverse hypothesis suggests that there is an infinite number of possible universes, each with different physical constants. In some of those universes, perhaps in very few, the constants and laws of physics are adjusted in such a way as to enable our existence.

¡Recibe nuestra newsletter!

    The data provided by you is processed by the Spanish Nuclear Society in accordance with EU Regulation 2016/679 on Data Protection, with the purpose of managing your requests, answering queries, administrative, statistical processing and sending SNE communications, about your activity, events, etc. The transfer of data is not foreseen (unless legally required) or international data transfers; and through the Privacy Policy you have all the rights that assist you in terms of privacy.